To innovate in the current climate, a Board must move beyond the clinical “Hockey Stick” projections that populate boardroom slide decks and confront the human psychology that often keeps organisations stuck in mediocrity.
As any seasoned director knows, strategy is a deeply human endeavour, fraught with social dynamics, cognitive biases, and the messy reality of risk appetite. Here is how the insights from Strategy Beyond the Hockey Stick intersect with the modern challenges of AI, geopolitics, and productivity.
The Social Side of Strategy
In their work, McKinsey partners Chris Bradley, Martin Hirt, and Sven Smit argue that the biggest hurdle to breakthrough strategy isn’t a lack of data; it’s the “Social Side of Strategy.” Strategy is developed by people with careers to protect and a natural aversion to being the outlier.
This leads to the power curve – where most companies sit in the middle, earning just enough to cover their cost of capital. Moving to the top quintile requires big moves that often feel psychologically risky to a Board, even when they are the most rational path for long-term survival.
1. AI Disruption: Overcoming the “Inside View”
The human brain is wired for linear thinking, but AI disruption is exponential. Boards often fall victim to the “Inside View” – believing their business model is more resilient than it is because we’ve always done it this way.
- The Human Challenge: Acknowledging that AI might render a core business model obsolete is emotionally taxing. It requires the Board to cannibalise current revenue streams to invest in the future.
- The “Hockey Stick” Trap: Management often presents AI initiatives as a slow ramp-up. Beyond the Hockey Stick suggests that to win, you must reallocate resources dynamically. If AI is disrupting your sector, shifting 1% of your budget isn’t a strategy, it’s a hobby.
2. Geopolitical Resilience: Courage in Uncertainty
The current landscape is defined by permanent volatility – trade wars, supply chain fragmentation, and shifting alliances.
- The Human Challenge: In times of high uncertainty, the human instinct is to wait and see. This leads to paralysis.
- The Strategic Pivot: Boards must move from just-in-time to just-in-case models. This involves a fundamental trade-off: lower short-term margins in exchange for long-term durability. This is a hard sell in a boardroom focused on the next quarter, but it is the essence of value creation in a polarised world.
3. The Productivity Crisis: Differentiated Improvement
Global productivity has stagnated, and many Boards respond by asking everyone to work harder. Beyond the Hockey Stick argues that you cannot be world-class at everything.
- The Human Challenge: It is socially difficult to tell one department they are getting world-class investment while another is getting bare minimum. However, “hair-spraying” resources across the whole company ensures that no one has enough to truly innovate.
- The Strategic Pivot: Boards must identify the 20% of activities that drive 80% of the value and disproportionately fund them. Productivity isn’t about doing more things; it’s about doing the right things with radical intensity.
The Human Trade-off: Risk vs. Return
For a Board, the trade-off between risk and return is rarely a math problem; it is a psychological balancing act.
- Fear of the “Big Bet”: Directors often feel safer approving five small, low-risk projects than one large, transformative bet – even if the five small projects are mathematically certain to lead to stagnation.
- The “Outside View”: To innovate, Boards must counteract internal optimism by looking at the data of what other companies in their position have achieved. If only 1 in 10 companies successfully pivots a legacy model, the Board needs to ask: “What are we doing that is ten times better than the others who failed?”
Practical Application for the Boardroom
To drive real innovation, a Board must disrupt its own social dynamics:
- Dynamic Resource Allocation: Re-baseline your budget every year. Move capital to where the disruption (AI) is happening, not where the legacy is.
- M&A as a Program: Don’t wait for the one perfect deal. Use programmatic M&A to buy the skills and tech needed to survive geopolitical shifts.
- Encourage Candour: Create a safe zone where directors can challenge the status quo without being seen as not a team player.
The Bottom Line:
Strategy is a game played by humans. To innovate, we must stop pretending it’s a science and start managing it as a social process that requires courage, candour, and a willingness to be uncomfortably bold.
Did you find these insights valuable? Follow Stewart & Smith Advisory for more expert guidance on navigating the complexities of business finance.